Question:
> > Actually I was thinking of cities like Vienna or Stockholm where the > rail station is downstairs in one of the terminal buildings, and this direct > rail link takes a passenger to a downtown station where he/she can > either walk to a downtown destination or walk through the station to > connect to another rail or metro. I prefer trains much more than busses. > In Vienna it’s across the street from the terminal, though there is an > underground walkway. > But almost every major European airport has a train connection of that > quality.
I suppose it depends how ‘major’ an airport is, but neither of the two busiest Scottish airports have rail connections. The new ATH still has a bus connection to the subway, right? What about BUD? — David Horne- www.davidhorne.net usenet (at) davidhorne (dot) co (dot) uk
Response:
> >> Because the OP was, I think, asking about local connections. > Actually I was thinking of cities like Vienna or Stockholm where the > rail station is downstairs in one of the terminal buildings, and this direct > rail link takes a passenger to a downtown station where he/she can > either walk to a downtown destination or walk through the station to > connect to another rail or metro. I prefer trains much more than
busses. Light rail from BWI will get you to Penn Station (railway) in Baltimore, but you have to change once. http://www.mtamaryland.com/services/lightrail/schedule/map.cfm However this doesn’t make much sense considering the short shuttle bus ride to BWI’s own rail station.
Response:
> In that case DCA (National Airport) qualifies (Subway comes to the Airport, > you can connect to Distance Rail at Union Station) but BWI, where you must > get on a shuttle for aobut 10 minutes to the on -airport rail station > does not.
As mentioned in another post, a light rail line does serve the BWI airport. Here is a link to an airport map that shows the location of the line: http://www.bwiairport.com/customer_assistance/airlines_services_map/ (Look near the bottom of the map, beside the International Terminal.) The shuttle bus to the Amtrak/MARC train station leaves from a stop close to the light rail station at the airport.
Response:
> Really? I was not aware of the light rail into the terminal. > But I come to BWI from DC, not from Baltimore, so this is one of those > experience limitations.
It’s at the far end of the terminal (the international end). Very easy not to notice if you always arrive by bus. miguel — Hit The Road! Photos from 35 countries on 5 continents: http://travel.u.nu Latest photos: Malaysia, Israel, Palestine, Austria, Thailand
Response:
>> While you are correct about this, the APTA table lists LR. As listed in > BWI’s website: > "Light Rail service is available to downtown Baltimore and Hunt Valley from > BWI." > The rail also goes to DC from BWI.
The light rail that’s actually at the airport only goes to Baltimore. To get to DC you need to take the shuttle bus to the Amtrak/MARC station or to Greenbelt Metro (all heavy rail). miguel — Hit The Road! Photos from 35 countries on 5 continents: http://travel.u.nu Latest photos: Malaysia, Israel, Palestine, Austria, Thailand
Response:
> Actually I was thinking of cities like Vienna or Stockholm where the > rail station is downstairs in one of the terminal buildings, and this direct > rail link takes a passenger to a downtown station where he/she can > either walk to a downtown destination or walk through the station to > connect to another rail or metro. I prefer trains much more than busses.
In Vienna it’s across the street from the terminal, though there is an underground walkway. But almost every major European airport has a train connection of that quality. A huge difference to the US where it’s a remarkable thing. miguel — Hit The Road! Photos from 35 countries on 5 continents: http://travel.u.nu Latest photos: Malaysia, Israel, Palestine, Austria, Thailand
Response:
>But almost every major European airport has a train connection of that >quality. A huge difference to the US where it’s a remarkable thing.
It’s not that remarkable. In the past year or two I’ve taken trains directly to or from the terminal at MDW, ORD, PHL, DCA, ATL, and SFO. I’ve observed the trains at CLE and STL although I didn’t happen to be going downtown from either. The airport that most desperately needs a rail link is LGA, and there’s a subway line not too far away, but the NIMBYs will never let it happen. — Regards, John R. Levine, IECC, POB 727, Trumansburg NY 14886 +1 607 330 5711 Member, Provisional board, Coalition Against Unsolicited Commercial E-mail
Response:
>>The airport that most desperately needs a rail link is LGA, and >there’s a subway line not too far away, but the NIMBYs will never let >it happen. >It’s much more complicated than that now. The Port Authority of NY/NJ >really has no interest in offering one-seat rides, because it doesn’t >make money on the largest portion of the trip (the subway) since it >doesn’t own it. That’s why you have these incompatible systems like >the one linking the "A" to JFK.
True. There was some thought of the JFK airtrain running on the LIRR tracks into Penn Station. The trains could do it, technically very close to LIRR, but I guess the politics were impenetrable. >If NIMBY was the only issue, you wouldn’t have an elevated rail line >carrying Amtrak trains going right through the area.
Uh, that line was built in 1916, around the time the NIMBYs’ grandmothers were born. I suppose that they could put the subway over the Grand Central Parkway, which is already fairly ugly, at vast cost. R’s, John
Response:
> > BWI – Shuttle bus [free] to heavy [really intercity] rail line (Amtrak, > MARC) > While you are correct about this, the APTA table lists LR. As listed in > BWI’s website: > "Light Rail service is available to downtown Baltimore and Hunt Valley from > BWI."
The intent of my list was to identify locations where there were bus connections to nearby rail service. This was in addition to the APTA list I cited, which already covered the airports with service directly into the terminals, so I didn’t repeat them. In some cases, the airports included in my list were duplicates to the direct service list on the APTA web site. Baltimore is such a case, as it has both a light rail line into the terminal, and a shuttle bus to the BWI Airport rail station where one can catch either Amtrak or MARC trains. The MARC trains will take a passenger into Baltimore or Washington DC. > ORD – Shuttle bus to nearby Metra line > Again, from ORD’s website: > "The Chicago Transit Authority’s Blue Line travels > between O’Hare and downtown Chicago."
As with Baltimore, this is an airport with both a direct connection (the CTA Blue Line) and a shuttle bus to a nearby rail station on the North Central line: http://metrarail.com/Sched/ncs/ohare.shtml
Response:
> The intent of my list was to identify locations where there were bus > connections to nearby rail service. This was in addition to the APTA > list I cited, which already covered the airports with service directly > into the terminals, so I didn’t repeat them. In some cases, the airports > included in my list were duplicates to the direct service list on the > APTA web site. > Baltimore is such a case, as it has both a light rail line into the > terminal, and a shuttle bus to the BWI Airport rail station where one > can catch either Amtrak or MARC trains. The MARC trains will take a > passenger into Baltimore or Washington DC.
Really? I was not aware of the light rail into the terminal. But I come to BWI from DC, not from Baltimore, so this is one of those experience limitations. Julie > > ORD – Shuttle bus to nearby Metra line > Again, from ORD’s website: > "The Chicago Transit Authority’s Blue Line travels > between O’Hare and downtown Chicago." > As with Baltimore, this is an airport with both a direct connection (the > CTA Blue Line) and a shuttle bus to a nearby rail station on the North > Central line: > http://metrarail.com/Sched/ncs/ohare.shtml
– Julie I could be wrong. My experience is limited to my experience. Check out my Travel Pages (non-commercial) at http://www.dragonsholm.org/travel.htm
Response:
>> Because the OP was, I think, asking about local connections. > Actually I was thinking of cities like Vienna or Stockholm where the > rail station is downstairs in one of the terminal buildings, and this direct > rail link takes a passenger to a downtown station where he/she can > either walk to a downtown destination or walk through the station to > connect to another rail or metro. I prefer trains much more than busses.
In that case DCA (National Airport) qualifies (Subway comes to the Airport, you can connect to Distance Rail at Union Station) but BWI, where you must get on a shuttle for aobut 10 minutes to the on -airport rail station does not. — Julie I could be wrong. My experience is limited to my experience. Check out my Travel Pages (non-commercial) at http://www.dragonsholm.org/travel.htm
Response:
> While you are correct about this, the APTA table lists LR. As listed in > BWI’s website: > "Light Rail service is available to downtown Baltimore and Hunt Valley from > BWI."
The rail also goes to DC from BWI. And National Airport does have metro right there. Last week we went to the Dominican Republic, flew back, got on metro took the train back to our home (well, my husband walked home (about a half mile) and I waited for him to drive to the station and pick up four suitcases. When we do backpack- style travel, we can walk to the metro and take train to either DCA or BWI. Julie y — Julie I could be wrong. My experience is limited to my experience. Check out my Travel Pages (non-commercial) at http://www.dragonsholm.org/travel.htm
Response:
>> BWI Baltimore/Washington Also a shuttle bus to the BWI station > on the main rail line between DC and Baltimore, Philly, New York. > I’m probably showing my bias here, but why not continue and say Stamford, > New Haven, Providence, and Boston (South Station).
Because the OP was, I think, asking about local connections. True BWI has a train station for Amtrak only a short shuttle ride away, and fits in this group, but it’s also light rail, the MARC system, which is local. — Julie I could be wrong. My experience is limited to my experience. Check out my Travel Pages (non-commercial) at http://www.dragonsholm.org/travel.htm
Response:
> Because the OP was, I think, asking about local connections.
Actually I was thinking of cities like Vienna or Stockholm where the rail station is downstairs in one of the terminal buildings, and this direct rail link takes a passenger to a downtown station where he/she can either walk to a downtown destination or walk through the station to connect to another rail or metro. I prefer trains much more than busses. Pete
Response:
> Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago > has the blue line ‘L’. What others? > Pete
Vancouver (YVR) will have it around 2008 or 09. They are about to start and it will be ready for the Olympics. Kent
Response:
> BWI Baltimore/Washington Also a shuttle bus to the BWI station > on the main rail line between DC and Baltimore, Philly, New York.
I’m probably showing my bias here, but why not continue and say Stamford, New Haven, Providence, and Boston (South Station).
Response:
> BWI – Shuttle bus [free] to heavy [really intercity] rail line (Amtrak, > MARC)
While you are correct about this, the APTA table lists LR. As listed in BWI’s website: "Light Rail service is available to downtown Baltimore and Hunt Valley from BWI." >ORD – Shuttle bus to nearby Metra line
Again, from ORD’s website: "The Chicago Transit Authority’s Blue Line travels between O’Hare and downtown Chicago." Also, and unfortunately, PVD won’t be next year.
Response:
> Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago > has the blue line ‘L’. What others?
BWI Baltimore/Washington has light rail – part of the Baltimore system – right at the terminal. Also a shuttle bus to the BWI station on the main rail line between DC and Baltimore, Philly, New York.
Response:
>Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the >airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago >has the blue line ‘L’. What others?
Newark International has New Jersey transit trains to Newark and Manhattan. Philadelphia international has direct trains to three different stations in Philadelphia. — Barbara Vaughan My email address is my first initial followed by my last name at libero dot it.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->> > Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the >> > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago >> > has the blue line ‘L’. What others? > For Chicago, there’s also the Orange Line ‘L’ to Midway. Also the South > Shore Line’s station in South Bend is at the South Bend airport (but who > would fly to South Bend to get to Chicago? Maybe to Michigan City…) > <http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/images/Chicago/SouthShore/Airpo…> >> PDX >> SFO >> ATL >> LAS (eventually) >> STL >> PVD (next year?) >> Washington-Reagen (not been there, but heard something about it???) > Yes, the terminal building is right next to the Metro station. > <http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/images/Washington/Metro/Airport…> >Add MSP > Cleveland. (Red Line to downtown) > <http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/images/Cleveland/Red/Airport.jpg> > Philadelphia. (Regional Rail to downtown, er, Center City) > Milwaukee. (Amtrak just opened a station at the airport, on the > Milwaukee-Chicago route) > And if it doesn’t have to be a one-seat ride: > Newark NJ (monorail to train to Penn Station in either Newark or New York) > New York (JFK) (Airtrain to Jamaica, where you can take either the subway > or the Long Island RR to Manhattan)
Here is a list of airports with a direct rail link into the airport terminals.: http://www.apta.com/research/stats/rail/airport.cfm The list is from APTA’s web site. It excludes places where you need a bus or van transfer, or where the line doesn’t come directly into the airport. (I think the only one missing on people’s suggestion lists so far is Baltimore’s light rail line): As mentioned by others, there are also airports where a short bus link will take passengers to a nearby rail station, or where the station is very close. Included would be the following: SAN – Scheduled bus to nearby rail lines (Amtrak, Coaster, Trolley) LAX – Bus to nearby light rail line BUR – Short walk to Metrolink commuter line SJC – Shuttle bus to Metro light rail and Caltrain stations OAK – Shuttle bus to nearby BART station BOS – Shuttle bus to "T" BWI – Shuttle bus to heavy rail line (Amtrak, MARC) ORD – Shuttle bus to nearby Metra line PBI – Shuttle bus to nearby commuter line (Tri-rail) FLL – Shuttle bus to nearby commuter line (Tri-rail) MIA – Shuttle bus to nearby commuter line (Tri-rail) MKE – Shuttle bus to nearby Amtrak station YUL – Shuttle bus to VIA Rail and AMT commuter stations The above came to mind, but there are probably many others.
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> > Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the > > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago > > has the blue line ‘L’. What others? > > Pete > PDX > SFO > ATL > LAS (eventually) > STL > PVD (next year?) > Washington-Reagen (not been there, but heard something about it???) > Add MSP
Add BOS
Response:
>> > Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the > > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago > > has the blue line ‘L’. What others?
For Chicago, there’s also the Orange Line ‘L’ to Midway. Also the South Shore Line’s station in South Bend is at the South Bend airport (but who would fly to South Bend to get to Chicago? Maybe to Michigan City…) <http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/images/Chicago/SouthShore/Airpo…> > PDX > SFO > ATL > LAS (eventually) > STL > PVD (next year?) > Washington-Reagen (not been there, but heard something about it???)
Yes, the terminal building is right next to the Metro station. <http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/images/Washington/Metro/Airport…> >Add MSP
Cleveland. (Red Line to downtown) <http://web.presby.edu/~jtbell/transit/images/Cleveland/Red/Airport.jpg> Philadelphia. (Regional Rail to downtown, er, Center City) Milwaukee. (Amtrak just opened a station at the airport, on the Milwaukee-Chicago route) And if it doesn’t have to be a one-seat ride: Newark NJ (monorail to train to Penn Station in either Newark or New York) New York (JFK) (Airtrain to Jamaica, where you can take either the subway or the Long Island RR to Manhattan) — Dept. of Physics and Computer Science Clinton, South Carolina USA
Response:
> Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago > has the blue line ‘L’. What others? > Pete
PDX SFO ATL LAS (eventually) STL PVD (next year?) Washington-Reagen (not been there, but heard something about it???)
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the > airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago > has the blue line ‘L’. What others? > Pete > PDX > SFO > ATL > LAS (eventually) > STL > PVD (next year?) > Washington-Reagen (not been there, but heard something about it???)
Add MSP
Response:
Which cities in Canada and the USA have direct rail links from the airport to downtown? Minneapolis has Metro Transit and Chicago has the blue line ‘L’. What others? Pete
Response: